Story Loom

Chapter 5: The Resurrection at the Altar

Carolyn Vance’s knees buckled.

She grabbed the back of the walnut pew in front of her to keep from collapsing onto the floorboards, her fingers clawing into the velvet upholstery. Her chest heaved beneath her black lace blouse, her eyes wide, glassy with a terror so profound it looked as though she were staring into the gaping mouth of hell.

""Carolyn?"" Judge Harrison Vance turned from the hymnal, his brow furrowing in irritation at his wife's sudden disturbance. ""What is it? Are you faint from the heat?""

Carolyn couldn't speak. Her lips moved soundlessly, opening and closing like a suffocating bird, her shaking finger still frozen in the air, pointing directly across the aisle at my chest.

Judge Vance followed her gaze.

The old judge froze.

The hymnal in his hands remained open to page 142, but his reading glasses slipped two inches down the bridge of his aristocratic nose. His jaw, usually clamped in that terrifying judicial sneer that had sentenced hundreds of men to hard time, went completely slack.

Beside them, Eleanor Miller turned around, annoyed that the sacred family moment was being disrupted.

My mother’s eyes met mine.

The lavender color of her suit seemed to bleed into her face, turning her skin the shade of curdled cream. A strangled, breathless squeak tore from her throat, her hand flying to her pearl necklace with enough violent force that the silk thread snapped.

Clatter-clatter-clatter.

Three dozen South Sea pearls bounced across the hardwood floor of the aisle, rolling between the polished shoes of the congregation, clicking against the stone base of the pulpit like hail on a tin roof.

The choir’s voices faltered.

The organist, sensing the sudden, violent rupture in the room, hit a sour, discordant minor seventh that died into a low, droning rumble through the pedal pipes.

The entire church of three hundred people fell into a dead, suffocating silence.

Mitch spun around from the front row, his handsome face flushed with irritation. ""Mom, what are you doing? Pick up your—""

The words died in his throat.

Mitch saw me.

He stood in the center of the sanctuary, framed by the life-sized portrait of his ""angelic dead sister"" and twenty dozen white funeral lilies. His bespoke suit suddenly looked two sizes too large on his frame, his arms hanging limp at his sides, his eyes bulging as if an iron band were tightening around his trachea.

I didn't cower. I didn't look down at the carpet.

I stepped out of the third pew into the center of the crimson runner.

My leather shoes clicked against the oak floorboards with a clear, sharp, rhythmic cadence that echoed off the high rafters like the cocking of a rifle.

One step. Two steps. Three.

I stopped five feet from the altar steps, looking straight up into the eyes of my brother.

""Happy Easter, Mitch,"" I said.

My voice was not loud, but in the petrified silence of the sanctuary, it carried to the back row of the balcony, clear as a silver trumpet.

Avery Vance stepped forward from the front pew, her green silk dress rustling against the wood. She looked from my face to the oil painting on the easel, then back to my face.

A high-pitched, hysterical laugh escaped Avery’s lips—the sound of a mind desperately trying to reject a reality that was shattering five years of her life.

""Mitch..."" Avery stammered, reaching out with both hands, her knuckles brushing against his stiff arm. ""Mitch, who is that? Why does she look like your sister? Who is this woman?""

Mitch didn't answer. His chest heaved with shallow, frantic breaths, his knuckles bunching into fists so tight his signet ring cut into his palm.

""She’s an impostor!"" Eleanor suddenly shrieked from the aisle, her voice cracking into glass-shattering hysteria as she lunged toward me with her manicured hands raised like claws. ""She’s a mentally ill girl from the county asylum! Security! Pastor! Get this trespassing lunatic out of my daughter's memorial service!""

""Don't you dare lay a finger on that child, Eleanor Miller,"" Ruth’s voice roared from the third pew.

Ruth stepped into the aisle, blocking my mother with the immovable bulk of an eighty-year-old oak tree.

Ruth reached into her heavy leather handbag, pulled out a thick, legal-sized manila folder stamped with the crimson seal of the Georgia Department of Public Health, and held it high above her head for the three hundred people in the pews to see.

""This is the certified birth certificate of Stacey Lynn Miller, born June 14, 2000!"" Ruth’s voice boomed through the sanctuary like an Old Testament prophet. ""And here is the quarterly rental ledger, signed in Eleanor Miller’s own hand, proving that for ninety-six months, this family has charged their living daughter four hundred dollars a month to sleep in a padlocked room while they stole two million dollars from the Vance Charitable Foundation!""

A collective, deafening gasp tore through the congregation.

Judge Harrison Vance lunged forward, his face mottled with purple rage, snatching the folder from Ruth’s hands.

His eyes tore across the documents: the bank wire confirmations, the signed rental receipts, the original hospital discharge papers from Emory University bearing his own foundation's grant reference numbers.

The judge looked up from the papers, turning toward Mitch with an expression of pure, unadulterated annihilation.

""Harrison..."" Mitch wept, dropping to his knees on the altar steps, reaching out his trembling hands toward his future father-in-law. ""Harrison, listen to me... it was my mother! She said we had to protect the family name! I was twenty-one! I didn't know—""

""Shut your mouth,"" Judge Vance whispered.

The judge turned his back on my brother as if he were a pile of rotted offal.

He walked slowly down the altar steps, stopping three feet from where I stood in my linen dress.

The seventy-year-old jurist, who had sent governors to prison and looked down on three generations of Southern politicians, slowly lowered his head. His shoulders hitched, a single, agonizing sob breaking through his iron composure as he looked into the face of the girl he had believed was bones in a cemetery plot.

""My God,"" Judge Vance choked out, tears streaming down the deep creases of his weathered cheeks. ""What have we done to you?""

Avery took three stumbling steps toward me, her hands shaking violently, staring at the scar along my hairline.

""The letters,"" Avery whispered, her voice barely more than a breath of wind. ""The letters I put in that room... you read them?""

""I read every one, Avery,"" I said softly, looking her dead in her weeping eyes. ""And every Easter, while you were on your knees praying for my soul... I was forty-five minutes down Highway 9, waiting for my brother’s party to end so I could go back to my cage.""

Avery spun on her heel, ripped the four-carat diamond ring from her left finger, and hurled it with all her strength directly into Mitch’s face.

The diamond struck him across the bridge of his nose, cutting the skin, sending a thin trickle of crimson down his cheek before clattering onto the brass communion rail.

""You monster,"" Avery screamed, her voice echoing off the stained-glass windows. ""You monstrous, lying sociopath!""

Mitch didn't look at her.

He was staring past the congregation, past the altar, toward the arched double doors at the rear of the sanctuary.

The heavy oak doors had just swung open.

Standing in the bright morning sunlight of the entryway were four armed officers from the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, accompanied by the United States Postal Inspector and two uniformed county deputies.

The lead investigator stepped into the center aisle, pulling a federal arrest warrant from his breast pocket, his voice echoing off the plaster walls with the finality of a closing iron gate:

""Mitchell Miller. Eleanor Miller. David Miller. You are under arrest for federal wire fraud, grand larceny, and conspiracy to commit identity theft.""

Mitch sat frozen on the altar steps, blood dripping from his nose onto his white rose, his eyes locked onto mine in a silent, pleading agony.

I looked at him for three seconds.

Then I turned my back on the altar, took Ruth’s arm, and walked down the crimson carpet toward the sunlight.

Related Stories