Chapter 4: The Counter-Suit

Judge Simmons leaned back in his leather chair, steepling his fingers together as he surveyed the wreckage of my parents' lawsuit.
""Well,"" the judge said, a grim, humorless smile touching the corners of his mouth. ""It appears the plaintiffs have brought a frivolous claim before this court, supported by falsified assertions of abandonment and financial contribution.""
He picked up a blue ink pen, tapping it rhythmically against the edge of the case folder.
""Your Honor,"" Robert muttered desperately, looking up with pleading eyes. ""Please... we’re her parents. Can't we reach some sort of mediation? Surely the property can be split—""
""Mr. Carter,"" Judge Simmons interrupted coldly, ""your daughter has maintained sole legal ownership and financial responsibility for 414 Miller’s Lane for twelve consecutive years. Under Virginia property law, your filing does not merely lack merit; it borders on attempted fraud.""
He looked directly at me. ""Commander Carter, does counsel for the defense wish to file a motion for dismissal with prejudice, along with a counter-claim for legal fees and harassment?""
I didn't hesitate.
""Yes, Your Honor,"" I said clearly. ""We move for immediate dismissal of Case 4238B, with prejudice, and request that the plaintiffs be ordered to cover all legal costs incurred by the defense.""
""Motion granted,"" Judge Simmons said instantly. He signed the bottom of the dismissal order with a sharp, decisive stroke of his pen. ""Furthermore, I am forwarding transcripts of today's proceedings to the Caroline County District Attorney's office to determine whether further investigation into the plaintiffs' falsified financial claims is warranted.""
Margaret burst into tears, burying her face in her hands as her social standing, her carefully guarded reputation, and her dreams of the highway payout evaporated in less than thirty minutes.
Robert sat paralyzed, staring at the defense table as if his entire world had just been detonated from the inside out.
""Court is adjourned,"" Judge Simmons announced, banging his gavel one final time.
---
Related Stories


